The night before the Emmys broadcast, Stayner was hit by a car on his motorcycle on his way home from work and died of fatal head injuries.14-year-old Timmy White was a pallbearer at his funeral. "He even told them a story about Steven (Stayner). Assistant Sheriff Strength said Stayner was on the waiting list for a job as a county jail guard. Steven Stayner, 14, is flanked by his father, Delbert (left) during a press conference after Steven and a young boy escaped from a sexual predator on Valentine's Day 1980 in Ukiah, Calif. Steven Stayner, celebrity savior of a young boy, was dead at 24. asked Lisa Hansell, then Cedar Lodge restaurant general manager. Cary Stayner's high school 1979 yearbook photo. "My sister and I both wanted to be the best at it. "They got him to a mental health center, but he left. His parents taught him to trust adults. He asked if Stevens mother had anything she could donate to the church. Whatever damage that had [been] inflicted on Cary, I think he kept to himself. I loved him a lot -- I don't know if he knew how much I did. "Then finally, things were getting to be normal and things were getting good, that's when Steven gets killed," she said. Lenna said she could remember one occasion in which Cary Stayner had made her feel uncomfortable. Rape and molestation victims were seen as damaged goods, Horowitz recalled. In 1959, he was arrested for robbery in Salt Lake City and spent six years in prison this would turn out to be the longest sentence hed serve for all the crimes he committed in his life. In Captive Audience, the Stayner Family Opens Up About Navigating - MSN Cary Stayner's July 29, 1999, booking mug. Her job was leading children in nature hikes. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window). Please visit once. its so fascinating to hear about the reverberations stories like this have on our personal lives, like the fear that you developed around visiting national parks as a woman. In the little time I worked with him, he just seemed like a regular person.". Part way through reading this and I want to flag that you describe the person who Parnell marries at 18 as a 15-year-old woman which is not great phrasing! Neighbors, well-wishers, gawkers and the media crowded the street to witness the . Steven Stayner was eventually reunited with his family and hailed as a hero. They were at the Merced River, she said, when he started removing all of his clothes. When Steven Stayner returned home, the whole family's focus was on him, she said. Unlike the first three murders, where he left virtually no evidence, he knew that he had left a very easy trail for investigators," Rowlands said. Regardless of his intentions, Cary's actions hurt his family all the same and took another son from Kay's life. Parnell re-named Steven Dennis Gregory Parnell, and they moved around California, from Santa Rosa to Willits to Fort Bragg. I remember watching I Know My First Name Is Stephen when it aired (I was 8) and it stuck with me for so long. He usually ordered a rum and coke. When she was murdered, her family and the park created the Yosemite Armstrong Scholars to keep Joies dreams and actions alive. leatherloom Mens Leather Jackets Bomber LeatherJacket, It can, of course, be prepared as a shot, or you can double it for a few shots, make a. Parnell was convicted on kidnapping and false imprisonment charges. [2] In 2002, Cary was convicted and sentenced to death for the murders of four women. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated by the guidelines laid out in our comment policy. In 1985, at the age of 20, Stayner married 17-year-old Jody Edmondson. He would later tell the FBI he started imagining killing women and girls when he was just 6 or 7 years old. He didnt want to talk about it, he was ashamed and he feared itd be framed as his fault. Meanwhile, Cary grew increasingly bitter about his family and the entire worlds focus on Steven, telling an interviewer: The way I see, just about anybody would have done the same thing in his shoes We never really got along that well after he came back All of a sudden Steve was getting all these gifts, getting all this clothing, getting all this attention. So I believe that there was some guilt with Cary on the fact that maybe he felt a little responsible," said childhood friend Mike Marchese in 1999. Heroism, tragedy and cold-blooded murder: The Stayner brothers. By that point I was 18 and had been to Yosemite several times but also was raised by a very paranoid, anxious, fearful mother (who I bonded with by watching forensics shows and true crime series lol), so it just added to my fear of stranger assaults and kidnapping that I had felt as a girl/woman. Hulus Captive Audience: A Real American Horror Story, dropped in April, but I didnt notice it until last week, and boy was it captivating! The film explores the trauma and psychological impact of Stevens abduction and the difficulties he faced trying to adjust to life after his escape. On my way home every day Carey would be pulled over to the side of the road next to the Merced River and would be there sun bathing. As hed feared, the revelation had dire consequences. She had a very popular personal blog once upon a time, and then she recapped The L Word, and then she had the idea to make this place, and now here we all are! Her other son, Robert, was in jail for drug, firearm and oral copulation charges. I Know My First Name is Steven was a massive hit, and inspired a new bout of press attention to the Stayners. "Cary was pretty much a loner. But a few quotes Cary had previously told media in the midst of his brother's fame led some to wonder if he was a disgruntled, jealous brother. Cary has a couple of nervous breakdowns. Hi! In 1999, he confessed to four killings. Amid the mayhem, Steven learned to live with the publicity, for better or worse. Steven, in a rarity for a kidnapped child, made his way back to his family after eight years of living under an assumed name and identity given by his groomer and attacker Kenneth Parnell.. "He loved Yosemite and in some way, it's sad. After Armstrong was reported missing, authorities went to her cabin and found debris -- broken sunglasses as well as a red mechanics hat -- and tire tracks. But, at the age of 24, Steven Stayner, by then a husband and father of two, was killed in a motorcycle crash. In a photograph taken by Juli Sund and released by Francis Carrington, Carole Sund (left) is shown with Silvina Pelosso in their room at the Cedar Lodge in El Portal shortly before they were killed in February 1999. Kenneth already had an extensive criminal record, including a conviction for kidnapping and sexually assaulting a nine-year-old boy back when he was 19 years old. I wanted to share the happiness we had, the good outcome, but then that had a bad side too.". Before he'd driven to the nudist colony, Lenna said, Cary Stayner had gone looking for them but Lenna and her sister were at their grandmother's house. Soon enough, an opportunity presented itself: Screenwriter JP Miller wanted to write a made-for-television movie about his life. "Dad" and saying his parents no longer wanted him. "Cary was very upset. Why does the name Stayner ring a bell? Hope to see more posts from you. Girls found him attractive, but introverted and aloof. "He was off. Chronicle photo by Frederic Larson, A photo of Yosemite serial killer Cary Stayner published in the 1979 edition of "El Rodeo," the Merced Union High School yearbook. The photographs were released by family members before a jury began deliberations in the murder trial of Cary Stayner. On December 4, 1972, Steven was abducted walking home from school - the beginning of a traumatizing, media-heavy journey for the Stayner family. Inside the Two Nightmares Lived by the Family of Steven Stayner - E! Online Steven drank heavily, did a lot of drugs, dated lots of girls, and eventually dropped out of high school. Lenna told "20/20" she had kept this story hidden for 20 years, never sharing it with anyone. You can also watch it in multiple parts on YouTube. One Brother Was a Hero, One Was a Serial Killer: New Docuseries Explores the Stayner Family's Plight. 'Captive Audience' Summary: Hulu Revisits the Stayner Family - People ", "To realize that the monster that did that was your own family, like, that's crazy. Captive Audience (TV Mini Series 2022) - IMDb At first, Stayner denied being sexually abused by Parnell. The boy was asked if he wanted to donate something to a church. But Steven and his mother didnt want to go through a second trial. Steven Stayner reunited with his parents In the early '80s, the story of Steven Stayner's childhood abduction and rescue riveted the nation. Cary Stayner became a lost soul. Classmates remember him as shy but a good kid who had holes in his shoes. what a great post ive found. When he got into the room, Cary pulled out a .22-caliber pistol, claiming he intended to rob the them. On Sept. 20, 1989, Steven Stayner was riding his new Kawasaki motorcycle without a helmet in the rain. He is also the prime suspect in the Sund-Pelosso case. I love stories like this! Lenna said he was like a "big teddy bear" toward her and her sister. The bodies of Carole and Silvina were found in their rental car a month later about 50 miles away, and investigators alerted by an anonymous letter that Cary said he wrote found Juli's body near a Don Pedro Reservoir overlook. But at the same time, I still have a hard time looking at him as a monster. He was given a new identity Dennis Parnell and for seven years endured sexual abuse at the hands of his captor. Despite the severe trauma that he dealt with when he lived with his kidnapper, Steven made a life for himself, marrying and having children. The movie does an excellent job of portraying the complex emotional journey of Steven and the devastating effects of child abduction. Her beheaded body was found near her cabin on July 22. Cary was arrested the same year, and in the trials that followed he was convicted of all four women's murders and sentenced to death. He joined the publication in 2021 on the crime beat. His seven-year-old brother, Steven Stayner, was kidnapped by child molester Kenneth Parnell in 1972, when Cary was 11, and held captive for more than seven years before escaping and being reunited with his family. Cary was convicted and sentenced to death in 2002 for the murders of four women in 1999. "Cary started acting wildly inappropriately towards females. '", Looking back at what drove Cary to do something so heinous, the Stayners are stumped. Then all of a sudden its gone. "That's what was making people start talking about it with Steven, all his interviews and this movie. Steven Stayner, then 24, had married and had two children. He was sentenced to death in December 2002 and remains on death row. Im a Lesbian and I Want to Hate-Fuck These 9 Men So Hard Their Kindergarten Teachers Forget Their Own Names, FRIDAY OPEN THREAD: Lets Warm This House Up, Autism Is Not a Trend, but There Are Problems With How Its Discussed Online, The Sounds of Gen-Z: Five Queer R&B Artists That Blend Sultry with Sweet, Its Time To Face Facts: Ill Never Be a Lipstick Femme. "We wanted to go back to our normal lives," Steven's younger sister, Cory Stayner, tells the Captive Audience producers. "I said, "Well, yeah. (I dont want to hide that it was really super white for many years, but it seems like theyre concretely changing that now.). His death dealt another blow to the family - but not its last. Parnell told Steven that his parents didnt want him anymore and that the court had appointed him Stevens new legal guardian. In the 1970s, they constituted Cary and Steven, their three sisters, and their parents, Kay and Delbert Stayner. Lenna said she'd told no one this for 20 years. Stayner confessed immediately, to sexually assaulting and murdering the women, but later pled not guilty by reason of insanity. But in 1972, the family would begin a traumatizing and highly publicized journey that spanned 30 years. But many experts and loved ones say he had longstanding fantasies about harming people, and that his actions were in no way tied to how he felt about his younger brother having the spotlight. Who Are Steven Stayner Siblings? Meet Cary Stayner And Cory Stayner Bafflingly, she was given a reunion with Steven, apparently became friends with Stevens Mom, testified against Parnell and claimed she had no idea he wasnt Stevens own kid. But the family has since dealt with several tragedies along the way, including Steven's death and his older brother's incarceration for murder. Every summer for the past twenty years, a group of 15-18 year old women and non-binary femmes go to Yosemite for twelve days. Even outside of press conferences he held with family members and Timmy, the cameras didn't turn off. Steven had been taught to respect adults in authority but wasnt well-versed in the dangers of talking to strangers, so he agreed to let Murphy and his friend Kenneth Parnell give him a ride home, where they could meet his mother. As he was driving, he said, she fell through the window of the vehicle and started running. Strength said Cary Stayner's arrest has stunned the community. I think my mom might donate something,' " Stayner told authorities years later. The Stayner family home in Merced, Calif. Child kidnap victim Steven Stayner, 23, is seen smoking a cigarette inside a car about a year before his death. Stayner was the third of five children born in Merced, California to Delbert and Kay Stayner. 27 of 38 28 of 38 The Stayner family home in Merced, Calif. SUSAN RAGAN Show More Show Less 29 of 38 Child kidnap victim Steven Stayner, 23, is seen smoking a cigarette inside a car about a year . Back in Merced, Stevens parents were growing increasingly alarmed. Between February and July of 1999 he brutally murdered three tourists and a naturalist in Yosemite National Park: Carole Sund, 42; Juli Sund, 15; Silvina Pelosso, 16; and Joie Ruth Armstrong, 26. (AP Photo/The Modesto Bee, Al Golub), Yosemite murder suspect Cary Stayner is escorted following a hearing at the Mariposa County Courthouse Monday, July 16, 2001, in Mariposa, Calif. (AP Photo/The Fresno Bee, Craig Kohlruss), FBI agent Jeff Rinek cracked the Yosemite murder case. In February of 1999, three women whod been staying at Cedar Lodge while traveling in Yosemite were found murdered: 42-year-old Carole Sund, Caroles fifteen-year-old daughter Juli Sund and their family friend, sixteen-year-old Silvina Pelosso. At that age shes a girl/child. Although an almost four-year age gap separated the two brothers, with Cary being the eldest of all five siblings, they seemed incredibly close. Steven's disappearance was a . "Kind of hard to do that when you got the cameras everywhere though.". "He was just our friend," she said. The Truth About The Kidnapping Of Steven Stayner - Grunge "There's a big part of me that still wonders if he still thinks of those two little girls that adored him so much because we think about him all the time, and I wonder if he still thinks about us.". It seemed like she was alone," he said during his taped confession. A photo taken after Steven's escape to freedom shows him flanked by his beaming father, Delbert. They . In the same episode, she asks: "How much more could happen in our lives in one lifetime?". Parnell, whose kidnapping of Steven Stayner was turned into a television movie, was convicted in the 1972 kidnapping of Stayner, who was then 7, and the 1980 kidnapping of a 5-year-old boy. I guess I was jealous. She was packing her car as she prepared for a trip. They reported him missing to the police, and his face was all over the news. "I know that Steven was really happy about the way that it turned out," Jody says, adding that his press interviews tied to the movie helped him finally open up about the abuse he faced as a child. "I don't think he did it. Jesse Houtz, co-owner of Cedar Lodge Restaurants, said Cary Stayner would hang out at the bar, but often kept to himself. The Stayners and law enforcement launched a massive effort to find Steven Stayner. Cary Stayner is shown in a booking photo Monday, Dec. 4, 2000, at the Mariposa County Adult Facility in Mariposa, Calif. Growing up, brothers Cary and Steven Stayner shared a home . The pair then hitchhiked to the Ukiah police station. "My mom said, 'You know the girls that went missing? Click here to make sure you get the news. He made some money consulting on a TV film written about his horrifying ordeal and got a reward for rescuing the 5-year-old boy. Two of the women's bodies were found burned in the trunk of their charred vehicle, one had her throat cut and the final victim had been decapitated. Steven Stayner became a household name in 1980 when he returned home after being kidnapped about seven years earlier. He told doctors at a hospital where he was treated that he began to participate in homosexual activities at the reform school where he was sent for stealing a car. The family learned from the FBI that Cary Stayner had tried to kill them on three separate occasions including after he'd killed Armstrong. Let's have a personal and meaningful conversation and thanks for stopping by! "Everyone living in this community knew and embraced this monster, who was capable of such horrors.". By that point, Steven had gotten married and had two children, was working with child abduction groups to educate kids about kidnapping and had a job at a pizza parlor. By 19, he had wed Jody Edmondson a girl whom he met at the butcher shop where he worked and started a family. But he had already lost faith in the agency he had taken pride in serving. But he was unable to develop any sort of interpersonal relationships with any women," said TV reporter Ted Rowlands. SF tourists go in droves to In-N-Out. Then on Valentine's Day, 1980, Stayner left a Mendocino County cabin and walked into the Ukiah police station along with 5-year-old Timmy White, another Parnell kidnap victim, whom he had helped to free. "It was the biggest deal in Hollywood," says Corin Nemec, who portrayed Steven as a teenager. Voice in the Dark, by Sean Flynn for Esquire (2004) Flynn recounts the major events in Cary and Stevens lives and crimes, and interviews Cary in prison, and Kenneth Parnell, who was then living alone in a white cement row house in Berkeley. . (AP Photo/Ben Margot). Much like Steven's, their disappearance shocked the nation and dominated headlines as investigators frantically searched for them. The acting in the film is top-notch, with impressive performances by Corin Nemec and Luke Edwards, who play Steven Stayner at different stages of his life. My mom went off the deep end, and um, harbors a lot of guilt. The case was never solved. For seven years, Steven was held captive and sexually molested by Parnell, who forced Steven to call him "Dad" and told him his parents had abandoned him. Cary Stayner caught up with her and slit her throat. Uncle Jerry's murdered. "I want to speak out for my family, who's been affected. The new Hulu docuseries pulls back the curtain on how one of the most prominent true crime families complete with a child kidnapping victim and his serial killer brother navigated trauma under a microscope. Stars Todd Eric Andrews Ashley Stayner Kay Stayner See production, box office & company info Watch on Hulu S1 on Hulu.com and the Hulu app Add to Watchlist Added by 4.4K users (Remarking on people calling his brother a hero, Cary once said, "The way I see it, just about anyone would have done the same thing in his shoes."). 3. Ten years after Steven died in a motorcycle accident at the age of 24, something inside of Cary snapped. "We figured he would be a cartoonist by now," Shertz said. ", Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. I loved Cary. That was his therapy that helped him through everything.". Start receiving breaking news emails on wildfires, civil emergencies, riots, national breaking news, Amber Alerts, weather emergencies, and other critical events with the SFGATE breaking news email. Heroism, tragedy and cold-blooded murder: The Stayner brothers - SFGATE This rage is starting to bubble up. When authorities realized who Steven was the Stayners were called to come see him, and the grand reunion was met with fanfare. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Copyright 2009 - 2023 The Excitant Group, LLC. A San Francisco Gate article from 2003 also digs in to why Parnell was not charged with sex crimes, quoting former Mendocino County district attorney Joe Allen. "A lot of attention went to Steven we all got a little jealous," says one of the Stayner sisters in Hulu's upcoming docuseries Captive Audience: A Real American Horror Story. Cary Stayner will forever be known for marring Yosemite's reputation as a peaceful retreat with the brutal murders of four innocent women. In February 1999, Carole Sund; her 16-year-old daughter, Juli Sund; and friend Silvina Pelossa, an exchange student from Argentina, were staying at the lodge. New Hulu Series Captive Audience Takes On Steven Stayner's Abduction Cary Stayner was convicted in both state and federal courts. (CHRIS STEWART/THE CHRONICLE). "It's hard for me to think about him being behind bars, and I wonder what it's like for him being there, because he loved to be outside," Lenna said. The case remains unsolved. If you haven't listened to episode 138 yet, make sure you do that before you jump He skidded trying to avoid a car pulling out of a driveway and fatally struck his head. Inside the Hunt for San Francisco's Notorious Doodler Serial Killer: 'His Victims Deserve Justice', The True Story Behind Hulu's 'Boston Strangler', The Best True Crime Documentaries to Stream Now, All About Kara Robinson, Whose Daring Escape from Captivity Led to Her Predator's Capture, Cold Cases Heat Up: How Advances in DNA Technology Are Helping to Bring Justice for Victims, Sam Elliott Calls SAG Awards 2023 Win 'the Most Meaningful Acknowledgement of My 55-Year Career', San Francisco Police Release Age Progression Drawing of Doodler Serial Killer, Golden Globe Winner Paul Walter Hauser Leads Rousing Tribute to Late 'Black Bird' Costar Ray Liotta, The Best TV Shows on Amazon Prime Video to Stream Now, How a Serial Killer Was Caught While 'Literally Trying to Clean His Van of Evidence', The True Story Behind the Broadway Musical 'Parade', Starring Ben Platt, The True Story Behind Hulu's 'Welcome to Chippendales'. The day Armstrong disappeared, Cary Stayner was driving his car to Foresta when he saw the young woman. After Steven's death, his parents sold the house. I remember watching I Know My First Name is Steven because I remember that scene where the line is drawn from. And uh, such a happy part that turned into such a dark part of our life," she said. Stayner family's woeful history - SFGATE "This was supposed to be easy for Cary. Cary's uncle Jerry, who he was very close to and lived with, was shot and killed by a home invader with Jerry's own shotgun. Steven Stayner as a child (Courtesy of Hulu). He graduated from Merced High School, and worked as a window installer for a glass company in nearby Atwater. "He would show us how to point your toes or how to put your arms forward and dive perfectly into the pool," she told ABC News' "20/20" in an exclusive interview. Now Steven Stayner's brother, Cary, 37, was the prime suspect in the decapitation killing of a young naturalist, and the FBI suggested he had a role in the murder of three Yosemite tourists in February - Carole Sund, her daughter, Juli, and family friend Silvina Pelosso. Lenna said police told her family Cary Stayner tried three times to kill them. Nobody could have known.". At the age of 18, he married a 15-year-old girl, and they had a daughter and divorced four years later. The separate stories of Steven and Cary Stayner made national headlines, first in 1980 and then nearly 20 years later. One was fairly violent," Flynn said. The two-hour special airs Friday. "He knew everyone and talked to everyone, but I can't say anyone was his best friend or not.". Steven Stayner - Wikipedia Police tracked down Barbara Mathais, whod been listed as Stevens mother while they lived together, but she was never charged for her participation in Stevens abuse (although neither was Parnell, so!). Where is Kidnapping Survivor Timmy White, Steven Stayner, Now? | True 20/20: Evil in Eden Special on Steven and Cary Stayner.